Skip to content
Independent reporting

A Two Second Guitar Riff Led One Court to a Seven Word Rule for Every Producer

The pale stone Potter Stewart United States Courthouse in downtown Cincinnati under a blue sky
Share X Facebook Email

Every producer who has ever lifted a drum hit, a horn stab or a vocal snippet from an old record has wondered the same thing: how small does a sample have to be before nobody can come after you for it?

In the United States the honest answer is that it depends on where you get sued. Two federal appeals courts looked at almost the same question about a decade apart and came to opposite conclusions. One of them summed up its view in seven words that still get quoted in studios and law schools: “Get a license or do not sample.”

This is a plain language explainer, not legal advice. If you are releasing music with samples, talk to a music lawyer.

Two kinds of copyright in one record

Most recorded songs carry two separate copyrights. One covers the composition, the notes and words as written, usually owned by a publisher. The other covers the sound recording, the specific performance captured on tape, usually owned by a record label. Sampling copies a piece of the actual recording, so it can touch both.

For decades courts handled small borrowings with an old principle called de minimis, short for a Latin phrase about the law not concerning itself with trifles. If the amount copied was too small or unrecognizable to matter, there was no infringement. The question at the heart of sampling law is whether that principle applies to sound recordings at all.

The two second riff

The 1975 Funkadelic track “Get Off Your Ass and Jam” opens with a solo guitar figure lasting about four seconds: three notes of a chord played one at a time in very quick succession, which the trial court described as a “high-pitched, whirling sound.” In 1990 N.W.A. released “100 Miles and Runnin’.” According to an expert for the plaintiffs, a two second piece of that guitar figure had been copied, its pitch lowered, and the result looped and extended to 16 beats. It appears in five places in the song, each looped segment lasting around seven seconds.

The case that reached the courts was not really about N.W.A. “100 Miles and Runnin’” was used on the soundtrack of the 1998 film I Got the Hook Up, released by No Limit Films. The plaintiffs included the publisher Bridgeport Music and Westbound Records, which claimed the copyright in the Funkadelic sound recording.

The federal district court in Tennessee looked at the sample and decided it was de minimis. Too small, too altered, not actionable. Westbound appealed.

A bright line in Cincinnati

In 2005 the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, which covers Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee and sits in Cincinnati, reversed. Its reasoning turned on how federal copyright law describes the rights of sound recording owners. In the court’s reading, the owner of a sound recording has the exclusive right to duplicate it, and any copying of the actual recording, however short, needs permission. The court wrote: “Get a license or do not sample. We do not see this as stifling creativity in any significant way.”

The effect was to remove the de minimis defense for digital samples of sound recordings in the Sixth Circuit. The court was careful to note that other defenses still existed, especially fair use, the argument that a new work transforms the original rather than simply reusing it. But the shortcut of saying “I only took a sliver” was gone.

The music industry noticed. The New York University musicologist Lawrence Ferrara, a sampling expert, called the effect on sample based music “extremely chilling, because it basically says that whatever you sample has to be licensed, in its most extreme interpretation.”

The ruling traveled abroad as well. In November 2008 Germany’s Federal Court of Justice decided in Kraftwerk’s “Metall auf Metall” case that even tiny fragments of a recording can be protected and that sampling a drum beat can infringe. That decision cited Bridgeport, though only in passing.

The horn hit in Vogue

Eleven years later, the question came up again in the Ninth Circuit, which covers California and much of the West. This time the defendant was Madonna.

VMG Salsoul owned the recording of “Ooh I Love It (Love Break)” by the Salsoul Orchestra, from the early 1980s. It claimed that “Vogue” used a single horn hit and a double horn hit copied from that track without a license. The sample in question lasted no more than 0.23 seconds and appeared intermittently in the song rather than forming its backbone.

The district court sided with Madonna on de minimis grounds. In 2016 the Ninth Circuit affirmed, and in doing so it confronted Bridgeport head on. It held that the de minimis defense does apply to sound recordings and that Congress never eliminated it. The section of the copyright statute that the Sixth Circuit relied on, the court said, was written to limit the rights of recording owners, not expand them. The panel acknowledged that the Sixth Circuit had held the opposite, but said that “like the leading copyright treatise and several district courts,” it found “Bridgeport’s reasoning unpersuasive.”

The Ninth Circuit’s test is whether an average audience would recognize that the new work took from the original. It leaned on its own earlier decision in Newton v. Diamond, a 2003 case over a Beastie Boys sample, which used the same average listener approach. A 0.23 second horn hit buried in a dance track did not clear that bar.

What the split means for producers

The result is what lawyers call a circuit split. In the Sixth Circuit, Bridgeport is still the rule, and any unlicensed sample of a recording is a risk no matter how small. In the Ninth Circuit, a tiny, unrecognizable sample may be defensible. Several district courts elsewhere, including courts in New York, Florida, California and Louisiana, have rejected or declined to follow Bridgeport.

None of this makes small samples safe. The de minimis defense is something you argue after you have been sued, and a court still has to agree that the copying was trivial. Fair use is decided case by case. Clearing a sample, getting permission from both the label that owns the recording and the publisher that owns the composition, remains the only way to know you are covered.

It also explains some habits that producers take for granted. Replaying a part with new instruments sidesteps the sound recording copyright, though not the composition. Making sounds from scratch avoids both. Beyond that, the answer to how small is small enough still depends on which courthouse you end up in.

Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress, public domain

Share X Facebook Email

The Daily Brief

The essential stories, without the noise.

A concise briefing delivered directly to your inbox.

Free to join. Unsubscribe any time.

Powered by Reach Response